Lottie and Hannah are celebrating the end of their school exams at Hannah's family holiday home in Devon. Lottie, whose snarky social media posts about a local music festival riles the locals, is found dead, and few mourn her. When another body is found, Detective Matthew Venn is called in. Pressure mounts to find the killer when Hannah's father, a powerful political figure, brings attention to the case. Thinking that the reason for the deaths is buried in the past, Venn and his detectives face obstacles at every turn from both the local community and Lottie and Hannah's families. Some secrets are meant to be kept secret.
The character Matthew Venn is a polar opposite of Cleeves' other detectives. He is quiet and still battles demons from his childhood. It took me a while to warm up to him, but with each successive novel, Cleeves reveals another layer, making Venn more relatable. In this book, Venn also addresses personal issues involving his husband that leave him vulnerable. The book is wonderfully written, with a complex storyline that draws the reader in. The characters are nuanced and the plot well crafted.
4.5/5 stars.
Thank you, NetGalley and Minotaur Books, for an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own. The publication date is September 29, 2026.
For more information:






